Review, Oct-Dec '26

↑

January 01, 2027

WIP

Table of Contents

Books

Old Babes in the Woods, by Margaret Atwood

No man in the house described our situation. Of course, everyone has a father—and I had one too, though at that date I wasn’t sure this father was still what you’d call “alive.” When I was four or five my mother told me she’d changed him into the garden gnome that sat beside our front steps; he was happier that way, she said. As a garden gnome he didn’t need to do anything, such as mow the lawn—he was bad at it anwyay—or make any decisions, a thing he hated. He could just enjoy the weather.

When I was wheedling her over something she’d initially denied me, she’d say, “Ask your father,” and I’d trot out and hunker down beside the garden gnome—hunker just a little, as he wasn’t much shorter than me—and stare into his jovial stone face. He appeared to be winking.

“Can I have an ice-cream cone?” I’d plead. I was sure that he and I had a pact of sorts—that he would always be on my side, as opposed to my mother, who was on her own side. It gave me a warm feeling to be with him. It was comforting.

“What did he say?” my mother would ask when I went back in.

“He said I can.” I was almost sure that I’d heard a gruff voice mumbling from within his grinning, beareded stone face.

“Very well, then. Did you give him a hug?”

“Yes.” I always hugged my father when he’d allowed something marginally forbidden.

“Well done. It’s nice to say thank you.”

— Old Babes in the Woods, pp. 61-62

Old Babes in the Woods is a sad, thoughtful, and witty book; as almost all Atwood’s books are. My Evil Mother and Metempsychosis are two of my favorite short stories of all time.

The days pass. I’m biding my time. I’m meditating. Perhaps my understanding of this phenomenon has been upside down. Perhaps I was a woman to begin with—maybe even this particular woman, Amber, with her wardrobe of jokey T-shirts—and I was sent into a snail in order to learn something of deep importance to my soul. But what could that be? To pay homage to the immediate, such as the rich veins and cells of edible greens and the heady, intoxicating scent of decaying pears? To appreciate the simple joys of the universe, such as congress with a fellow snail, snails? Was that it? What am I missing? It is what it is? I am what I am? What am I?

— Old Babes in the Woods, pp. 151-152

Several stories in this collection follow the characters of Nell and Tig from Moral Disorder. Nell’s point of view in Moral Disorder was veiled autofiction, similar to Elaine’s in Cat’s Eye, but here the veil is lifted: Nell is Atwood herself.

I should give up. I’m the wrong person, Nell thinks. The wrong reader for you. I’m sorry. All I can say is: I hear you. Or I hear something. Or I’m trying to hear something. Yes?

— Old Babes in the Woods, pp. 210

I hope that this will not be the last piece of fiction Margaret Atwood publishes, she seems healthy and sharp as ever, but it would be a worthy sign-off if it comes to that:

She smooths out the piece of paper carefully and stores it away in her suitcase. It’s a message, left by Tig for her to find. Magical thinking, she knows perfectly well, but she indulges in it anwyay because it’s comforting. She’ll take this piece of paper back to the city, but what will she do with it there? What does one ever do with these cryptic messages from the dead?

— Old Babes in the Woods, pp. 253

Story Ranking:

  1. My Evil Mother
  2. Metempsychosis: Or, the Journey of the Soul
  3. Wooden Box
  4. A Dusty Lunch
  5. Old Babes in the Woods
  6. Widows
  7. Morte de Smudgie
  8. Two Scorched Men
  9. First Aid
  10. Airborne: A Symposium
  11. Bad Teeth
  12. Impatient Griselda
  13. The Dead Interview
  14. Death By Clamshell
  15. Freeforall

The first four are 5/5 Atwood, the last two 3/5, the rest 4/5. Overall I loved this book, but the middle section, while housing my two favorite stories, felt disconnected from the rest; it lacked the powerful emotional and thematic throughlines of Moral Disorder.

— 4/5 —

Klara and the Sun, by Kazuo Ishiguro

When the Mother next spoke, it was more obvious she was speaking to me.

‘It must be nice sometimes to have no feelings. I envy you.’

— Klara and the Sun, pp. 97

Klara and the Sun read like a children’s novel: an existential and devastating children’s novel. I’d fallen in love with Klara within the first few pages, and I was in tears before page 40.

’I think I hate Capaldi because deep down I suspect he may be right. That what he claims is true. That science has now proved beyond doubt there’s nothing so unique about my daughter, nothing there our modern tools can’t excavate, copy, transfer. That people have been living with one another all this time, centuries, loving and hating each other, and all on a mistaken premise. A kind of superstition we kept going while we didn’t know better.’

— Klara and the Sun, pp. 221

One thing that stood out to me, and that I don’t see discussed much in other reviews, was the extreme individualism emphasized in this near-future society. I found it chilling and bleak that every character, besides perhaps Rick, so readily accepted “lifting.”

Mr Capaldi believed there was nothing special inside Josie that couldn’t be continued. He told the Mother he’d searched and searched and found nothing like that. But I believe now that he was searching in the wrong place. There was something very special, but it wasn’t inside Josie. It was inside those who loved her.

— Klara and the Sun, pp. 302

The day I spent reading Klara’s story was one of the most powerful emotional experiences I’ve had in my entire life. It is now days later and I still cannot think about the book without crying. It is by far my favorite Ishiguro novel, and the best thing I’ve read besides maybe Cat’s Eye. I can’t believe I wrote that “maybe,” but it’s true.

— 5/5 —

Sense and Sensibility, by Jane Austen

Elinor agreed to it all, for she did not think he deserved the compliment of rational opposition.

— Sense and Sensibility, pp. 236

My experience reading my first Jane Austen novel, Sense and Sensibility, went as follows:

  1. this is boring and difficult to follow;
  2. ok, it’s actually quite a pleasant and cozy story;
  3. I think Jane Austen might be a comedic genius;
  4. oh…

I found Volume II to be a witty and insightful piece of writing, but I was unsatisfied with the way things turned out in Volume III. I’m not against happy endings—in fact I welcome them, especially in stories of this ilk—but it felt contrary to all that I had previously perceived as biting, progressive commentary. I loved the characters that were featured prominently in dialogue, but the eventual romantic entanglements were between people who’d had no interesting on-page interactions. Elinor and Colonel Brandon were the only compelling pair: I’m on team Brelinor!

— 3/5 —

A note on the 2026 film: A few days after finishing the novel, I got to go to the theater and see Georgia Oakley’s new adapation. In brief: I absolutely loved the movie. The pacing of a two hour film necessitated cutting down the coziness of the novel and—most to my chagrin—heavily abridging the many months Elinor and Marianne spent in London, but it nailed the sisters’ relationship, and both romances were done far better than the novel.

A second note on the 2026 film: I saw it in the theater again, and I think it is hands down one of the best movies of the year. It’s my favorite period romance story of all time. Being another week further detached from my experience reading the book, all of the pacing problems I noted above faded away. Oakley was trying for something different from the novel and, in doing so, improved on it.

The Tent, by Margaret Atwood

The Tent is by far my favorite of Atwood’s tiny prose-poem books.

Why do you think this writing of yours, this graphomania in a flimsy cave, this scribbling back and forth and up and down over the walls of what is beginning to seem like a prison, is capable of protecting anyone at all? Yourself included. It’s an illusion, the belief that your doodling is a kind of armour, a kind of charm, because no one knows better than you do how fragile your tent really is.

— The Tent, pp. 146

I loved this book the whole way through: it was thematically consistent, angry and despairing, but with intermittent sparks of hope. In terms of Atwood’s other work, this collection was very remeniscent of Surfacing; it also reminded me of Hannah Dierdorff’s Rain, Wind, Thunder, Fire, Daughter.

— 4/5 —

The Alibi Girl, by C. J. Skuse

I wish that Skuse would write more standalone books, it was fun to see her explore different characters—even if they were very similar to characters in Sweetpea. It’s not high art, but her stories are my comfort audiobooks. The narrator(s) once again knocked it out of the park: the emotion in their reading, and their varied character voices, bordered on one-woman voice acting. I do feel sorry for them, though, considering some of the accents they had to do…

— 3/5 —

The Lure of the Labrador Wild, by Dillon Wallace

I read this book for three reasons:

  1. it is prominently featured in The Labrador Fiasco, by Margaret Atwood;
  2. reading the history of Fairbanks (my home town) has got me very interested in northern exploration in the early 1900s;
  3. when I brought 1 and 2 up with my dad, he told me that he had read the book and that it was great!

The Lure of the Labrador Wild was an excellent adventure story, and I learned so much about the time period. In a way, it is more enlightening to read an account of one person’s experience than it is to read a history book: a historian won’t be interested in exactly the same questions that I am, but a memoir will often detail the minutia of daily life.

While we were paddling about we came upon two old and two young loons. The old ones tried to lure us away from their young, by coming very near the canoe. The young loons made frequent dives, but we succeeded in catching one. Finally, however, we restored it to its parents, and when the loon family was reunited there was great rejoicing in the household.

— The Lure of the Labrador Wild, pp. 71

I wonder how honest Wallace was about their unflinching positivity, considering he admits they lied to one another about their courage during the expedition. Regardless of how truthful or not the account was—and I suspect it was mostly true—I enjoyed reading about these friendly adventurers. They were more than a bit racist, but in the most benevolently ignorant manner possible.

— 4/5 —

The Door, by Margaret Atwood

Madelaine is only three

but she knows already

the baby’s too big for the carriage.

No matter how hard you cram it in,

one day, when it should be sleeping,

it will slip through a blank in your memory

and get away.

— The Door, pp. 8

I’m still not fully equipped to appreciate poetry, but I enjoyed reading this collection. It’s sort of a relief that Atwood’s poetry is not really for me: she’s written so much poetry that, if I were to include it, it would extend my project of completing of her bibliography by at least another year.

— 3/5 —

Beautiful World, Where Are You, by Sally Rooney

I enjoyed watching the Hulu/BBC adaptation of Normal People, and Sally Rooney’s books have been on my reading list ever since. While wandering the library last week, I picked up Beautiful World, Where Are You on a whim, choosing it over Normal People so that my first experience with her writing would be an entirely new story, untainted by my affection for a TV or Movie adaptation. I won’t beat around the bush: I despised this book.

The characters were one-dimensional and frustrating in every possible way: they were selfish, unintrospective, whiney, and entitled. Besides their frequently mentioned surface level traits—Simon is tall, blonde, and Catholic, Alice is a writer, rich, and had a breakdown, etc—I could not tell you anything about them. The only semi-interesting ideas were contained in the emails between Alice and Eileen, but those emails were completely detatched from their authors’ thoughts and behavior in “real life.” The emails also had no discernable character voice, so I felt that I was just reading the results of Rooney dumping her stream-of-concious thoughts onto the page: if not for the included names, I could never have figured out who wrote which email. Early on the detachment between email chapters and plot chapters seemed intentional, given the distant, voyeuristic, external third-person perspective, but eventually that went out the window and the prose started describing the characters’ inner thoughts. There were also numerous long, lurid sex scenes which seemed to serve no purpose beyond being an attempt to arouse the reader. I’ve never once felt like I was watching porn while watching a sex scene in a movie, but I started to feel like that while reading this book.

There are plenty of “horrible people in relationship drama” stories that I enjoy, so it’s not the premise that put me off: I quite liked Life Before Man, for example. I also generally love a book about an “unlikeable” character who isn’t punished, see Morvern Callar. The thing about those other books, though, is they are about interesting and relatable “terrible” people. There’s something page-turning about Rooney’s writing that compelled me to finish the book, but I’m not giving it any bonus points for that.

— 1/5 —

Normal People, by Sally Rooney

I think I’m done with Rooney. I listened to this on audiobook over the same period of days that I was reading a physical copy of Beautiful World. The book almost made me start to dislike the TV show: Edgar-Jones and Mescal were able to convey an interiority to Marianne and Connell, respectively, that I interpreted as complex and compelling; these same characters, as written by Rooney, are as bland and vapid as the characters in Beautiful World, Where Are You. The exploration of class dynamics was surface level, pretentious, and contrived. I will concede that the sex scenes in this book did feel character driven and purposeful, unlike those that I complained about in Beautiful World, so that is not a problem inherent to all of Rooney’s writing.

Can we pick anyone else to be the preeminent Millenial novelist? Ottessa Moshfegh would be my top choice, so long as an “older millienial” qualifies. Otherwise I’d maybe put forward Sophie Mackintosh, the author of The Water Cure: while I didn’t absolutely love that book, it was head and shoulders above Rooney, and I’m excited to read more work from Mackintosh. Coincidentally, The Water Cure was recognized on the same 2018 Man Booker Prize longlist as Normal People.

— 1/5 —

My Year of Rest and Relaxation, by Ottessa Moshfegh

This was good, I thought. I was finally doing something that really mattered. Sleep felt productive. Something was getting sorted out. I knew in my heart—this was, perhaps, the only thing my heart knew back then—that when I’d slept enough, I’d be okay. I’d be renewed, reborn. I would be a whole new person, every one of my cells regenerated enough times that the old cells were just distant, foggy memories. My past life would be but a dream, and I could start over without regrets, bolstered by the bliss and serenity that I would have accumulated in my year of rest and relaxation.

— My Year of Rest and Relaxation, pp. 51

I’ve been interested in Ottessa Moshfegh ever since I saw the film adaptation of Eileen a couple of years ago. Then, while watching the Jennifer Lawrence movie Causeway this past summer, I thought, “This reminds me of Eileen,” only reach the credits and discover that the screenplay was written by Moshfegh! I grabbed My Year of Rest and Relaxation from the library because they didn’t have Eileen, but also, similar to my first pick Sally Rooney book above, I thought it would be best to start with a story that I had no preconceptions of.

My visit to Dr. Tuttle that month was relatively unremarkable.

“How is everything at home?” she asked. “Good? Bad? Other?”

“Other,” I said.

“Do you have a family history of nonbinary paradigms?”

When I explained for the third time that both my parents had died, that my mother had killed herself, Dr. Tuttle unscrewed the cap of her value-sized bottle of Afrin, twirled around in her chair, tilted her head back so that she was looking at me upside down, and started sniffing. “I’m listening,” she said. “It’s allergies, and now I’m hooked on this nasal spray. Please continue. Your parents are dead, and … ?”

“And nothing. It’s fine. But I’m still not sleeping well.”

“What a conundrum.”

— My Year of Rest and Relaxation, pp. 83

My Year of Rest and Relaxation was, quite simply, incredible. It’s so very much my thing: it reminded me of Atwood’s writing in Edible Woman and Lady Oracle, mixed with Morvern Callar and The Sopranos by Alan Warner.

I thought about whatever subliminal impulse had put me on the train to Farmingdale. Seeing Reva in full-blown Reva mode both delighted and disgusted me. Her repression, her transparent denial, her futile attempts to tap into the pain with me in the car, it all satisfied me somehow. Reva scratched at an itch that, on my own, I couldn’t reach. Watching her take what was deep and real and painful and ruin it by expressing it with such trite precision gave me reason to think Reva was an idiot, and therefore I could discount her pain, and with it, mine. Reva was like the pills I took. They turned everything, even hatred, even love, into fluff I could bat away. And that was exactly what I wanted—my emotions passing like headlights that shine softly through a window, sweep past me, illuminate something vaguely familiar, then fade and leave me in the dark again.

— My Year of Rest and Relaxation, pp. 166

The characters were so specifically drawn: they were fascinating, mean, hilarious, sad, gross, and loveable. Similar to Morvern Callar, I see most critics—even those who purportedly loved the book—describe the unnamed narrator as “unlikeable.” And similar to Morvern Callar, I completely disagree: I loved her. Yes, she was often unpleasant and cruel, especially to her friend Reva, but there were also so many moments when her true empathy managed to peek through. I saw so much of myself in her behavior and her patterns of thinking: when you hate yourself, and other people just ignore, pity, or love you, it becomes unbearable: you want to make them see how despicable you really are.

Maybe they lived as real artists knowing all along that there were no pearly gates. Neither creation nor sacrifice could lead a person to heaven. Or maybe not. Maybe, in the morning, they were aloof and happy to distract themselves with their brushes and oils, to mix their colors and smoke their pipes and go back to their fresh still lifes without having to swat away any more flies.

“Step back, please.” I heard a guard say.

I was too close to the painting.

“Step away!”

The notion of my future suddenly snapped into focus: it didn’t exist yet. I was making it, standing there, breathing, fixing the air around my body with stillness, trying to capture something—a thought, I guess—as though such a thing were possible, as though I believed in the delusion described in those paintings—that time could be contained, held captive. I didn’t know what was true. So I did not step back. Instead, I put my hand out. I touched the frame of the painting. And then I placed my whole palm on the dry, rumbling surface of the canvas, simply to prove to myself that there was no God stalking my soul. Time was not immemorial. Things were just things. “Ma’am!” the guard yelled, and then there were hands gripping my shoulders, pulling me to the side. But that was all that happened.

“Sorry, I got dizzy,” I explained.

That was it. I was free.

— My Year of Rest and Relaxation, pp. 286-287

The detached, depressive atmosphere expertly toed the line between profundity and pitch black comedy. The ending was similar to the ending of another particular Alan Warner book—if you know, you know. Ottessa Moshfegh is going on the list: I want to read everything that she has ever written.

— 5/5 —

Music

The Precariat, by Tommy Lefroy

And I love you

But fuck, you don’t know how it feels

To be harbouring something that you’re gonna kill

Would I recognise it?

If I’m unsafe from myself

Could I recognise it?

Could I blame somebody else?

Is this how I’m supposed to feel now?

A new Tommy Lefroy album is always cause for rejoice. I played The Precariat on repeat for weeks after its release.

Made a refuge of your room

I would waste myself in defence of you

It’s a vulture state, and it’s stacked on us

My love won’t change it, it’s not enough

Totems on your nightstand

Will outlast me and the dollar

And you’ll have to find another

Friend to talk you through the end

I don’t love it quite as much as Born Blue, but that album set an incredibly high bar.

Map in the mail / Orangerie, songs by Olivia Barton

It’s the end of the year and I’m right where I’ve been

And it’s right where I’ll be if I go where I’m headed

I do not work hard, I wait to be found

That’s not the truth, but I like the sound of it

Some, and I’m a capitalist pig

I want to make money, I want to be big

But we’re getting married and sometimes I think

I’d be okay if I didn’t have anything

But you

And me

The dog

Sleeping

Olivia Barton is yet another one of favorite artists who doesn’t get nearly enough recognition. This release made me realize that, while I’d obsessively listened to everying she’s released since For Myself and For You, I’d never gone back to her earlier albums. Unsurprisingly, they are amazing as well.

← Review, Jul-Sep '26